Robert P. Churchill CBAP, PMP, CSM, CSPO, CSD, CLSSBB Process Analysis for Business and Industry I can help you... Analyze and Document Your Process

Control Systems Engineer

I have designed, maintained, updated, implemented, and commissioned many kinds of control systems in a variety of locations, architectures, and industries. I did this in the context of both projects and products. The salient features of control systems are sensing, comparison, and corrective output in real-time.

  • I started out by including specifications for control elements on the process diagrams I prepared for the paper industry. These were almost exclusively in the form of standalone loops that controlled a valve or generated and alarm based on a single, measured value. I learned about the wide variety of instruments that were available, and many of the controls were pneumatic.
  • The models I wrote for nuclear power plant simulators were not themselves control systems, but they included the actions of control systems, which gave me terrific training in the discipline. I also began to learn about logical controls, interlocks, recorders, accumulators, and the like.
  • The model-predictive control systems I wrote for the steel industry had to perform a lot of operations, calculations, and data exchanges, but generally didn't involve a lot of control values. Indeed, the point of those systems was to generate values for things that couldn't be measured, namely average and maximum differential temperature within a steel workpiece. The supervisory systems I wrote were referred to as Level II, while the PLC-based Level I systems did the heavy lifting. They managed all of the digital and analog inputs, outputs, control logic, limits, and alarms. The Level 2 system read certain state and instrumentation data from the Level 1 system and used that to perform its calculations. It sent proposed temperature and material handling setpoints back to the Level 1 system, along with some status and alarm information, and the Level 1 system performed the detailed actions necessary to reach the setpoints. The Level 1 systems were (at the time) programmed using a vendor-specific form of ladder logic. Ladder logic may be different than high-level or procedural code but it can still be organized in a clean, modular fashion or a big, jumbled mess. I saw it done both ways and preferred the former, but the latter did work. The Level I systems also incorporated PC-based HMI systems to handle the user interface and data logging functions. A lot of the instrumentation, local controls, and emergency cutoffs were colloquially referred to as "Level 0." I learned about end-to-end and enterprise controls, time calculations, historical logging, mutex permissions, and more.
  • I took over maintenance of a PC-based product used to control induction melting furnaces. This system was 10-15 years old by the time I started working on it. It was a DOS program written in C++ and communicated directly with the sensing and control hardware via serial ports. It was originally written as a fairly literal translation of the previous PLC control logic but later maintainers added two distinct generations of changes to the software. By the time I started it was something of an unholy mess but it worked and I was able to make it do everything it needed to. I learned a lot more about low-level hardware communications and things like interlocks and one-shots.
  • In my next position I modified low-level communications software that let PC host software talk to networks of far-flung HVAC controls. I got a better feel for dedicated equipment protocols, low-level TCP/IP packet management, and supporting multiple operating systems.
  • Two of the evacuation simulation systems I worked on included real-time communications and control elements. I was able to apply, and teach my colleagues about, much that I had learned previously.

I have always enjoyed writing graphics, animation, and user-interface code of all kinds, and those skills have found expression in a lot of my work.



CC0 if possible, else Creative Commons License CC Attribution 4.0. Full statement here.
Rights to third party linked and referenced materials are assumed to be held by their respective owners.